Chaotic Test and Non-Linearity of Abnormal Stock Returns: Selecting an Optimal Chaos Model in Explaining Abnormal Stock Returns around the Release Date of Annual Financial Statements

Document Type : Research Paper


1 Department of Accounting, Neyshabur Branch, Islamic Azad University, Neyshabur, Iran

2 Department of Accounting, Neyshabur Branch , Islamic Azad University, Neyshabur, Iran

3 Department of Statistics, Mashhad Branch, Ferdowsi University, Mashhad, Iran



For many investors, it is important to predict the future trend of abnormal stock returns. Thus, in this research, the abnormal stock returns of the listed companies in Tehran Stock Exchange were tested since 2008- 2017 using three hypotheses. The first and second hypotheses examined the non-linearity and non-randomness of the abnormal stock returns ′ trend around the release date of annual financial statements, respectively. While, the third hypothesis tested the potential of the chaos model in explaining future abnormal returns based on the past abnormal returns around the release date of the annual financial statements. For this pur-pose, BDS, Teraesvirta Neural Network, and White Neural Network tests were used to investigate its non-linearity. In addition, Lyapunov exponent, correlation dimension, Dickey-Fuller, and Hurst exponent tests were used for testing non-randomness and the fitness of AR, SETAR, and LSTAR models to determine the optimal model in explaining the abnormal returns utilizing R software. Results of these tests represented a non-linear and non-random process and chaos in the abnormal stock returns, implying the predictability of abnormal stock returns. Also, among three used chaos models, the LSTAR model had lower error and more predictability than the other two models.


[1] Abhyankar, A., L.S. Copel and, W.Wong, (1995).Nonlinear Dynamics in Real-Time Equity Market Indices:Evidence From the United Kingdom. Economic journal, 105(431), P. 864-880.
[2] Abrishami, H., Moeini, A., and Ehrari, M. (2002). Specific non-linear test for oil prices. Journal of Economic Research of Iran, No 10, Spring (in Persian).
[3] Chevallier.J.(2011). Non-parametric modeling of carbon prices. Journal of Energy Economics, P.1267–1282.
[4] Dibachi, H., Behzadi. MH, Izadikhah, M., Stochastic Modified MAJ Model for Measuring the Efficiency and Ranking of DMUs, Indian Journal of Science and Technology, 2015, 8 (8), P. 549–555, Doi: 10.17485/ijst/2015/v8iS8/71505
[5] Emrah Hanifi, F. (2017). SETAR (Self-exciting Threshold Autoregressive) Non-linear Currency Modelling in EUR/USD, EUR/TRY and USD/TRY Parities. Mathematics and Statistics 5(1): P.33-55.
[6] Federici.D., and Gandolfo.G.(2012). The Euro/Dollar exchange rate: Chaotic or non-chaotic. Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control, P.670–681.
[7] Ghaderi Moghadam.A, Jabbari Nooghabi.M, Rounaghi.M, Hafezi.MH, Ayyoubi.M, Danaei.A, Gholami.M.(2014). Chaos Process testing (Time-Series in the frequency domain) In predicting stock returns in Tehran Stock Exchange, Indian J.Sci.Res. 4 (6): P. 202-210.
[8] Horri.m.s, Hashemi.M(2016),nvestigation of Chaos Equations on Tehran Stock Exchange System, Journal of Modern Research in Decision Making,No 1,Spring, P.25-46 (in Persian).
[9] Hsieh, D.A. (1991). Chaos and Nonlinear Dynamics: Applications to Financial Markets.,Journal of finance.No.46, P.1839-1877.
[10] Hung,S.,& Tu,M.(2014). Is small actually big? The chaos of technological change. Journal of Research Policy. P. 1227–1238.
[11] Imamverdi, Gh., and Safarzadeh, S. (2015). Chaos and non-linearity test of stock price index in TSE.quarterly of financial economics and development, 9(33), winter (in Persian).
[12] Izadikhah, M., Using goal programming method to solve DEA problems with value judgments, Yugoslav Journal of Operations Research, 2016, 24 (2), P. 267 – 282, Doi: 10.2298/YJOR121221015I
[13] Khodawaici.Hasan, Vafamand.Ali (2013), Comparison of Forecasting on Nonlinear Models STAR And competing models, Journal of Economic Modeling, No 23, autumn, P.85-103(in Persian).
[14] Kuo.C-K, Lee.C-W, Lu.YG.(2012). Testing for Chaos and Nonlinearity in Taiwan Futures Returns”. International Journal of Intelligent Technologies and Applied Statistics. P.41 – 56.
[15] Lahmiri Salim. (2017). A study on chaos in crude oil markets before and after 2008 international financial crisis”. Statistical mechanics and its Applications, Volume 466, P.389-395.
[16] Mahaki, E. (2015). Investigating Chaos Theory in Stock Price of Pharmaceutical Companies Accepted in Tehran Stock Exchange”. Master's Degree in Accounting, Senabad Non-Profit Institution of Higher Education. (in Persian).
[17] Moeini, A., Abrishami, H., and Ahrari, M. (2006). Applying Lyapunov exponent to modeling the time series of oil price based on dynamic functions. Journal of Economic Research; No.76, P. 77-100. (in Persian).
[18] Moshiri, S. (2002). A Review of Chaos Theory and its Applications in Economics”. Journal of Economic Research, No. 12, Autumn 2002, P.30-71. (in Persian).
[19] Moshiri, S., and Forutan, F. (2004). Chaos test and future prices forecast of petroleum. Journal of Economic Research, 7(21), P.67-90 (in Persian).
[20] Moshiri, S., and Morovat, H. (2005). Investigating Chaotic Process in the Index of Total Returns of Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Economic Research, 7(25), P.47-67 (in Persian).
[21] Namazi. M; Hajiha, Z; Chenari Boket, H. (2015). Investigation of the Chaotic Process phenomenon in the price index and cash returns in Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of  Economics and Development Quarterly, ninth year, No. 33 (in Persian).
[22] Riahi Belkoei, A. (1943). Accounting theories. Translated by Parsaeian, A., Tehran: Terme Publishing (in Persian).
[23] Salami, A. (2002). Chaotic trend test on stock returns in Tehran Stock Exchange. Journal of Economic Research, No. 5, P.35-71 (in Persian).
[24] Scheinkman,J.A.B.Lebaron,(1989). Nonlinear Dynamics and Stock Returns.Journal of Business, NO.62, P.311-377.
[25] Shakeri, Z., Homayounfar, M., Falahi, M., Sherbaf Tabrizi, S. (2015). Investigating Chaos Theory in Gold Coin Price in Iran. Journal of Monetary and Financial Economics, 22(10), P.84-103 (in Persian).
[26] Tong, H. and Lim, K.S. (1980). Threshold Auto-regression, Limit Cycles and Cyclial Data. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, B42, P.245-292.
[27] Tong, H. (1990), “Nonlinear Time Series, A Dynamical System Approach”, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
[28] Tong, H. & Yeung, I. (1991). On tests for Self-exciting Threshold Autoregressive-Type Non-linearity in Partially Observed Time Series. Applied Statistics, 40: P. 43-62.
[29] Vandrovych,V. (2007) Nonlinearities in Exchange-Rate Dynamics: Chaos?; Social Science Research Network, No. 945797.
[30] Yousefpoor, p Esfahani, M.S; Nojumi, H. (2008). Looking for Systematic Approach to Select Chaos Tests. Applied Mathematics and Computation. No. 198, P.73–91.
[31] Zeranezhad, M and Teimouri Asl, Y. (2011). Investigating stock returns¢ fluctuations in Tehran Stock Exchange using chaotic systems. Journal of Monetary and Financial Economics, 1(1), Spring and Summer (in Persian).
[32] Zeranezhad, M.., and Raufi, A. (2015). Daily Market Forecast of Tehran Stock Exchange: An Assessment and Comparison of Linear and Nonlinear Methods. Journal of Monetary and Financial Economics, No. 9, Spring and Summer (in Persian).
Volume 6, Issue 2
Corrected Proof
Spring 2021
Pages 321-333
  • Receive Date: 24 October 2019
  • Revise Date: 25 February 2020
  • Accept Date: 12 April 2020